The Difference Between Heirs and Legatees in South African Law
When someone passes away, their estate must be administered and distributed to the persons entitled to receive it. In South African succession law, two terms that often arise in this process are heir and legatee. Although both refer to beneficiaries of a deceased estate, they do not mean the same thing.
Understanding the distinction is important when interpreting a Will and determining how a deceased estate should be distributed.
What Is an Heir?
An heir is a person who inherits the whole or a share of a deceased estate, either in terms of a valid Will or through the rules of Intestate Succession.
Where a deceased person leaves a valid Will, the Will may provide that a person inherits the entire estate, a portion of it, or the residue of the estate.
The residue is what remains after the estate's liabilities, administration expenses, taxes, and any specific testamentary gifts have been dealt with.
For example, if a Will directs that the residue of an estate must be divided equally between the deceased's three children, each child inherits a share of the residue as an heir.
A person may also inherit as an heir when a deceased person dies without a valid Will. In such circumstances, the estate is distributed according to the rules of Intestate Succession, principally governed by the Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987.
What Is a Legatee?
A legatee is a person who receives a specific gift, known as a legacy, under a valid Will.
A legacy may consist of a particular asset, such as a motor vehicle, jewellery, artwork or immovable property, or it may be a specified sum of money.
Unlike an heir, who inherits the whole or a share of an estate, a legatee receives a particular benefit identified in the Will.
A legatee does not have to be related to the deceased. A testator may leave a legacy to a family member, friend, charitable organisation or any other person or entity.
Example: If a testator bequeaths their motor vehicle to a friend and directs that the residue of their estate be divided equally between their children, the friend is a legatee in respect of the vehicle, while the children inherit the residue as heirs.
A legatee's entitlement remains subject to the proper administration of the estate and the applicable legal requirements before distribution can take place.
Can a Person Be Both an Heir and a Legatee?
Yes. A person may be both an heir and a legatee if the Will grants them different benefits in different capacities.
For example, a testator may leave a family heirloom to their daughter and direct that the residue of the estate be divided equally among their children.
In this case, the daughter receives the heirloom as a legatee and inherits a share of the residue as an heir.
The distinction depends on the nature of the benefit received under the Will.
What Happens If There Is No Will?
When a person dies without leaving a valid Will, they are said to have died intestate.
In these circumstances, the estate is distributed according to the rules of Intestate Succession under the Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987, subject to other applicable legal provisions.
The persons entitled to inherit depend on the deceased's surviving spouse, descendants, and other qualifying relatives as provided for by law.
As there is no Will creating specific testamentary gifts, there will generally be no legatees in an intestate estate.
However, where a valid Will disposes of only part of an estate, the portion not dealt with in the Will may devolve in accordance with the rules of Intestate Succession. As a result, heirs and legatees may both feature in the administration of the same estate.
Why Does the Distinction Matter?
The distinction between heirs and legatees is more than a matter of terminology. It determines the nature and extent of a beneficiary's entitlement in a deceased estate.
An heir inherits the whole or a share of the estate, while a legatee receives a specific gift provided for in a valid Will.
Understanding this difference assists in the correct interpretation of Wills, the proper administration of deceased estates and the determination of beneficiaries' rights.
To Sum Up
An heir inherits the whole or a share of a deceased estate, either in terms of a valid Will or through the rules of Intestate Succession. A legatee, on the other hand, receives a specific testamentary gift created by a valid Will.
The administration and distribution of deceased estates are regulated by the Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965, while Intestate Succession is principally governed by the Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987.
A clear understanding of the distinction between heirs and legatees helps ensure the correct interpretation of Wills, promotes certainty in estate administration and assists beneficiaries in understanding the basis of their entitlement.
Comments